Friday, June 6, 2008

first week

Up until now, as a history major, I have concentrated mainly around the World War II and Holocaust era. I am glad now that I have decided to take classes that are centered closer to home. I took Rita Napier's history class on the plains indians and that was where I first learned about the Kennewick Man. Of course we have all learned about the white man's mistreatment of the Native Americans and their culture, but after taking that class and learning what I am now in this class, it's unfortunate to know that the mistreatment is still going on today to a certain extent. The battle over the Kennewick Man is a big example of how the U.S. government seems almost indifferent to the beliefs and wishes of Native Americans. In Napier's class we watched a great video which brought up a lot of different instances of the battles that are currently going on to get the bones of native people from museums so they can be properly buried. Of course scientists and other researchers want to run tests to learn more about the people who first inhabited North America, but we need to think about who those tests are affecting. I feel almost a little disappointed in myself for not being more educated on topics such as these earlier in life. Controversies such as this will continue on for years to come, if they are ever solved at all.

1 comment:

Stephanie Bray said...

You bring up a good point about the controvery between Native Americans and people that would like to further scientific research at all costs. Scientific research is certainly important and without it we would not have as much knowledge as we do. It is important to understand what happened in the past so that the future can and will be better. However, the government has ignored these people's rights, blatantly lied to them, and made excuses for their poor behavior for too long. Scientific research should have a plan behind it. How long is this research scheduled to last? They claim to be conducting the research without harming the Kennewick Man but I am rather skeptical on that. If they did eventually give the Kennewick Man back to his people for burial, would they even get all of it back or would parts of it be kept for museum display and further scientific inquiry or academic purposes? Science is very useful in all of our lives but the spiritual beliefs and values of the area's Native Americans should be respected in the process.